On Thu, 10 Feb 2005, Chris Buechler wrote:
> On Thu, 10 Feb 2005 10:44:13 -0500, Daniel L. Hunter
> <dhunter at techmethods dot com> wrote:
> > First, please forgive my ignorance. I'm a programmer, not a network
> > guy. And before I get flamed, I did search the archives and didn't find
> > anything relevant to my problem.
> > I'm testing out m0n0wall on a WRAP board. During this testing phase
> > there is only one machine on the LAN side while the rest of my network
> > (~ 10 machines) is on the WAN side. I have a DSL connection using an
> > Efficient 5861 DMT Router. DHCP is enabled on the DSL router. Several
> > of the machines on the WAN side are getting their IP from the DSL DHCP
> > server. The WAN interface on the m0n0wall is set up as Type=Static.
> > The DHCP server on the m0n0wall is not enabled. In other words, I don't
> > want m0n0wall to have anything to do with distributing IP addresses.
> > M0n0wall's WAN interface has a static IP address as will the machines on
> > the LAN side.
> > The problem I'm having is that when the m0n0wall is connected to the
> > network, it seems to take all of the leases from the DSL DHCP server and
> > knock the rest of the DHCP enabled machines on the WAN side off the
> > network.
> Somebody posted something similar within the past couple months, iirc.
> I don't believe any answer was given. Can't say that I've seen it
> myself. I believe the other person that reported this was using DHCP
> on the WAN, which makes this at least a little more feasible.
> Have you been able to sniff the network to see what's going on? If
> you can tcpdump to a file while it's doing this and email me the data,
> maybe I can see something in the output.
> Technically this shouldn't be feasible. Even if m0n0wall requested an
> IP from DHCP a billion times, the DHCP server should only give it one
> since it should always be requested from the same MAC address.
Though if it's inappropriately acting as a DHCP *server* on the WAN side
it could screw things up.