[ previous ] [ next ] [ threads ]
 From:  Jonathan Owens <niralisse at gmail dot com>
 To:  m0n0wall at lists dot m0n0 dot ch
 Subject:  Re: [m0n0wall] Using m0n0 under VMWare as a "real" firewall?
 Date:  Thu, 21 Sep 2006 09:12:32 -0700
I ran a similar setup for a bit while I waited for my Netvista to 
arrive. It sounds like you've done things well so far, as I don't see 
any obvious problems with your setup. One thing I encountered when doing 
this was an onboard NIC that simply didn't work for LAN access. The 
behavior was somewhat similar: the local machine could get to the LAN 
port via the bridged NIC, but no other machines would even get IP 
addresses. You might ensure that both NICs are of high quality before 
troubleshooting software further.

Barring that, I have to say that the web-only failure of your other 
clients is rather strange, do other services (such as email) work? 
Typically if you can ping by hostname, you're home free, so try some 
other services and see what you get.

Be patient, the VMWare m0n0wall is probably the most difficult platform 
to get running.

Francois Boulanger wrote:
> Hello! My old P133 that ran smoothwall blew up on me, so being a bit
> adventurous, I decided it might be fun to run m0n0 under VMWare as the
> primary firewall for my home.
> Has anybody ever tried (and succeeded) at doing this?
> A picture being worth a 1000 words, here's how the network is setup :
> http://www.ioverflow.net/pics/m0n0_network.jpg
> But something's not right with my configuration. Here's what I know :
> -under VMWare's Network editor, VMNet2 is bridged to my PC's first NIC,
> NIC1. (In windows, that nic has no protocols installed on it, except 
> for the
> VMWare bridge). This NIC is directly connected to my ADSL modem.
> -under VMWare's Network editor, VMNet0 is bridged to my PC's second NIC,
> NIC0. (In windows, that nic is configured with all protocols). This 
> NIC is
> connected to a switch wich links all the PCs in the house.
> -my m0n0 virtual machine has Ethernet 1 - LAN assigned to VMnet0
> -my m0n0 virtual machine has Ethernet 2 - WAN assigned to VMnet2
> m0n0 is configured correctly as far as i can see:
> - it can connect and obtain an IP adress from the ADSL modem
> - On the PC that's hosting the Virtual m0n0, I can obtain a DHCP 
> adress from
> m0n0 on GREEN (nic0) interface, and I can surf the web, everything works
> perfectly.
> - I did not setup any specific rules or NATting on m0n0. Outbound access
> should work for all my lan.
> but here's the problem : On the other workstation in the home, 
> (workstation
> 1) :
> - I can obtain a DHCP adress from m0n0
> - I can access m0n0's webGUI
> - I can ping m0n0
> - I can ping m0n0's WAN IP
> - I can ping m0n0's WAN gateway
> - DNS resolution works fine
> - I can even ping external websites using their IP and DNS,
> -.... but, for reasons unknown, I cannot access anything on the internet.
> Internet surfing, MSN, etc... nothing works. my browser seems to connect,
> but waits for a while and says that the connection was reset.
> The behavior is identical in Linux or Windows. I tried replacing the hub
> with a switch, same problem.
> Now, I don't consider myself a top notch network expert, but i'm no 
> slouch
> either, and I can't figure out what's wrong here. I've got more info if
> you're interested in trying to solve this mystery...(Ethereal packet
> sniffing on the WAN and the LAN, logs of dropped packets on m0n0 for no
> apparent reason, content of /status.php, etc).
> I'm stumped.
> Any ideas?
> Thanks!
> Francois