|
||||||||||
Sorry, i meant TCP of course... Was very late ;) > The proof of this would exist in the logs. When the lockup occurs, do you > see multiple drops for TCP 21, or whatever port your FTP control session > is on? I`ll check that. Default rule logging was disabled... ----- Original Message ----- From: "krt" <kkrrtt at gmail dot com> To: "Christopher M. Iarocci" <iarocci at eastendsc dot com> Cc: "Hans Mojave" <root1981 at gmail dot com>; <m0n0wall at lists dot m0n0 dot ch> Sent: Sunday, May 27, 2007 7:03 AM Subject: Re: [m0n0wall] FTP upload problem through monowall > Sounds like the small state table problem, where a regular session is > being clobbered by the new sessions (each file is a new TCP session in FTP > land). Since m0n0wall is stock tuned for tiny little "my lightbulb > consumes more power" routers, this is how it is. > > The proof of this would exist in the logs. When the lockup occurs, do you > see multiple drops for TCP 21, or whatever port your FTP control session > is on? > > FTP itself doesn't use UDP, so there is no issue there (though there might > be a trickle of UDP data involved, like DNS queries and maybe backend > authentication traffic like RADIUS) > > > Unfortunately, there aren't many ways of working around it at the time > being for 1.2 - state table size is supposedly a compile time variable. I > hope that we'll see some method of state table size entry method, and > perhaps a smarter overload algo in 1.3, where idle time is considered for > reaping before session age. > > > > > > > Christopher M. Iarocci wrote: >> No solution here, but thought I'd report the same exact problem with 2 >> separate m0n0walls. One running 1.23 and the other running 1.3b2. One >> of mine is connected to a cable modem, the other is connected to a Cisco >> router that is connected to a 10MB fiber connection. >> >> Chris >> >> >> Hans Mojave wrote: >>> Hi there, >>> >>> I´m running monowall 1.3b2 on a Wrap2E, using it as dsl-router... >>> (internal 1gbit switched / adsl2+ 16m/1m) >>> >>> When i upload many small files to an external ftp server (e.g. typo3 >>> installation and templates ~1800files) it happens that the ftp >>> connection is hanging. This happens round about every 200Files: >>> >>> -> File is uploading... Upload speed decreases to 0, ftp connection is >>> hanging. >>> >>> i have to hard-terminate the tcp session. Reconnect and resume uploading >>> the next ~200files with fullspeed . >>> >>> >>> Its not a dsl-modem, ftp-server,dsl-connection or software problem. >>> Tested that with Dlink804hv routers, 3 Pcs running different ftp >>> software (windows tcp/syn connection limit was removed). >>> Downloading of many small files is no problem. Also uploading through >>> ssl tunnels for example is stable. Uploading big files is no problem at >>> all. >>> >>> Is there an issue with the often changing data (udp) ports in monowall, >>> which is charateristc for ftp? >>> >>> >>> Sorry for bad englisch and best regards >>> Hans >>> >>> >> >> >> >> --------------------------------------------------------------------- >> To unsubscribe, e-mail: m0n0wall dash unsubscribe at lists dot m0n0 dot ch >> For additional commands, e-mail: m0n0wall dash help at lists dot m0n0 dot ch >> |